How to Avoid Student Loan Scams: Recognizing Red Flags and Taking Action

Yellow warning sign showing a scam alert, reminding student loan borrowers to watch for red flags and protect their personal information.

What Are Student Loan Scams and Why Are They Spreading?

Student loan scams are fake offers, services, or messages that claim to help student loan borrowers eliminate their debt or reduce their payments, but are actually designed to steal money or personal information. These scams are becoming more common, especially as more people struggle with rising student loan balances and confusing repayment programs.

Many of these scams target borrowers who are desperate for relief. A scammer might offer help with debt relief or promise lower monthly payments, but then demand upfront fees or personal data. Some might even pretend to be from the federal government.

If you have student loans or are looking into repayment options, it’s important to know how to recognize these red flags. According to the Federal Trade Commission, many scam companies use high-pressure tactics and promise results that sound too good to be true.

The Role of Federal Student Loans and Legitimate Support

To avoid scams, start by understanding how real federal student loan programs work. If you have federal student loans, your loan is handled by a legitimate loan servicer approved by the Department of Education. These loans are supported by the federal government, and services like repayment plans or consolidation are always available without charging fees.

Don’t let scam companies convince you to pay for help you can get for free. A real servicer will never ask for your FSA ID or require payments before offering support. If someone claims they can cancel your student loans immediately or get you forgiveness “guaranteed,” that’s a major red flag.

At Credit.org, we offer guidance to help you navigate your education debt safely. Start with this helpful article: Understanding What Student Loan Forgiveness Really Is.

Know the Signs of a Scam: Grammatical Errors and Other Red Flags

Scammers often give themselves away through sloppy communication. Watch for grammatical errors, typos, or strange phrases in emails or texts. Real government agencies use clear, professional language.

Also, look out for email addresses that don’t match the organization’s website, official sounding names like “National Student Aid Center,” or messages that urge you to act quickly or “act fast” to avoid losing your forgiveness opportunity.

These pressure tactics are meant to scare you into making a rushed decision.

How Identity Theft Can Happen Through Loan Scams

Scammers aren’t just after your money. Many are trying to steal your identity. When you give away personal details—like your account information, bank account number, or credit card number—you open the door to identity theft.

Some scammers may ask for your FSA ID, claiming they need it to help you with forgiveness. But your FSA ID is your legal signature for federal student aid. Sharing it gives someone full access to your student loan records. Never share it with anyone, not even a company offering “help.”

If you think your identity may have been stolen or your information compromised, follow these steps:

  1. Change your FSA ID password immediately.
  2. Notify your loan servicer.
  3. Report the scam to the Federal Trade Commission at IdentityTheft.gov.
  4. Read 5 Steps to Take If You Are the Victim of a Loan Scam for more support.

How Scammers Misuse “Loan Forgiveness” Language

Scammers love to talk about student loan forgiveness, especially now that many borrowers are confused about their options. Terms like total loan forgiveness, loan cancellation benefits, and forgiveness programs may be used to trick you into thinking you qualify for a benefit you’ve never heard of. This has led to a rise in student loan forgiveness scams targeting confused borrowers.

While real loan forgiveness programs do exist—especially for federal loans—they usually have strict eligibility rules and require years of consistent qualifying payments. Anyone who promises instant results is probably lying.

The Department of Education does not offer forgiveness in exchange for a fee, and it does not cold-call borrowers to advertise benefits.

If a company says they’ll get you forgiveness “no matter what,” that’s a sign of a scam.

Text reading ‘Don’t Get Scammed’ with a stopwatch, urging student loan borrowers to act quickly and avoid fraud.

Spotting Fake Loan Debt Relief Companies

Many debt relief companies claim they can erase your debt or lower your payments with a secret solution. They may say they’re a “document preparation service,” or that they’re working closely with the Department of Education, but they’re not.

These fake loan debt relief companies often:

  • Promise a special deal if you “act now”
  • Use high-pressure tactics to get you to pay quickly
  • Demand upfront payment before doing anything
  • Say they’ll avoid default or stop collections immediately

Even when they send you paperwork, it may not be valid. You might be signing over access to your loan account, or agreeing to let them auto-debit your checking account each month without doing anything for you.

When you are contacted online, pay close attention to the sender's email address; it may look official at first glance, but if you're dealing with college debt in 2025 then you grew up with the internet and you know to verify everything and never give out your username and password to a third party.

For more tips, check out Avoid Student Loan Scams – VSAC.

Income-Driven Repayment Plans Are Always Free

One of the most common scams involves charging people for something that’s already free. Income-driven repayment plans (IDR plans) are designed to make your monthly student loan payments affordable based on your income and family size.

There are four major IDR plans available through the federal government, including:

  • Income-Based Repayment (income based repayment plans)
  • Pay As You Earn (PAYE)
  • Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE)
  • Income-Contingent Repayment

If a company asks for money to enroll you, it’s a scam. You can apply for these repayment plans directly through your loan servicer or studentaid.gov, and there is no charge.

Some scammers say they can “simplify the process” or offer “professional help,” but what they really do is fill out forms you could complete on your own for free. You don’t need to pay for repayment options, repayment terms, or to adjust your monthly payment.

Never Pay Upfront Fees or Share Sensitive Data

Legitimate help with your student loans never starts with a bill. Scammers may charge monthly fees, ask for a “processing” fee, or say they need payment before services begin. Others might ask for your credit card number to “hold your spot” or confirm your identity.

These tactics are illegal. Federal law prohibits companies from collecting advance fees for student loan debt relief. Real help is available without paying anything upfront.

Also be cautious of companies that claim to offer free services or free assistance, then surprise you with hidden costs. Always read the fine print.

You should never give out:

  • Your bank account number
  • Your credit card number
  • Your FSA ID
  • Your Social Security number (unless dealing directly with a verified government website or servicer)

If someone says you need to pay or provide sensitive data before they’ll help, walk away.

Don’t Be Fooled by Official-Looking Names or Logos

Scam companies often create fake brands that sound like government agencies. They might use names like “Federal Loan Assistance Department” or “National Student Relief Center.” These official sounding names are designed to confuse you.

Some scammers go a step further, using fake logos and copycat websites that look similar to real federal sites. Always verify the site you’re using ends in .gov; for example, studentaid.gov or consumerfinance.gov.

You can also check if a company is legitimate through the Federal Trade Commission, or by contacting your real loan servicer.

Understand the Role of Student Loan Servicers

If you have federal student loans, you are assigned a student loan servicer to manage your account. Your servicer provides details about your loan terms, helps you apply for payment plans, and keeps track of your loan balance.

Scam companies may say they’re affiliated with your servicer or the federal loan servicer, but they’re not. They might even ask you to “switch” providers or sign a written agreement giving them permission to take over your loan management.

This is almost never necessary and could result in lost payments, late fees, or worse. Always contact your loan servicer directly for help. If you’re unsure who your servicer is, use your FSA ID to log into studentaid.gov and find out.

You can also get support from trusted nonprofit organizations like Credit.org. Read How to Talk to a Student Loan Officer or Debt Collector for advice on staying in control of your student debt.

What Is Legitimate Loan Consolidation?

Some borrowers are told they must consolidate their direct loans right away to qualify for forgiveness. Others are promised lower monthly payments or reduced loan terms through private consolidation.

Here’s what to know:

  • Loan consolidation through the federal government is real, and it’s free.
  • A direct consolidation loan lets you combine multiple federal loans into one.
  • You apply directly through studentaid.gov, not through a third-party company.

Scammers may use this process to gain control of your account. Once you give them your login, they can redirect your payments or withdraw funds from your account.

Private consolidation is different. If you refinance with a private loan, you may lose access to federal benefits like income-driven plans or loan forgiveness programs.

Always research carefully before you consolidate your federal student loans, and never agree to consolidation through a company that cold calls you or demands fees.

Private Loans vs. Federal Loans: Know the Difference

Many scam companies target people with private loans, promising to reduce balances, stop collections, or erase interest. But private lenders don’t offer the same protections or programs as federal student loans.

If a company says they can change your private loan into a federal one, or guarantee loan forgiveness, they are likely lying. Even if you’re struggling with a private lender, only that lender can change your repayment terms or offer relief.

Watch out for claims that a company requires immediate action or says they work with “federal partners.” These phrases are designed to confuse you.

When in doubt, contact your loan holder directly, or seek help from a trusted nonprofit instead of private companies making big promises.

Protecting Your FSA ID and Online Login Credentials

Your FSA ID is your key to accessing all federal student loan services. It should never be shared with anyone, not even a company offering to “help” you. Scammers who get this information can change your loan details, redirect payments, or commit fraud in your name.

You should only use your FSA ID on the official studentaid.gov site or when working with an approved servicer. No one else should ever ask for your login, password, or account information.

If someone says you must “talk directly” to a representative and asks for login info, it’s a trap. Hang up and call your servicer using the number on your loan statement.

Watch for Unrealistic Promises and False Claims

Some scams are easy to spot because they just sound too good to be true. A caller might say:

  • “We’ll forgive your student loans today!”
  • “You don’t need to make any more payments.”
  • “This program is ending, and you must enroll now.”
  • “We’ll cover your living expenses while you wait.”

These are classic false claims. In reality, forgiveness takes time, and no one can guarantee your eligibility. Real programs require an application, documentation, and often years of repayment.

Scammers may also use official looking names or say they are a government agency, when they are not. They may even forge written agreements giving them power over your loan.

Always verify any claim before you sign or send money.

How to Report Scams and Get Help

If you’ve been contacted by a scammer or think you’ve already been affected, take action immediately.

Here’s what you can do:

And most importantly, don’t go through this alone. Credit.org offers trusted help to guide you through your options and protect your financial aid and future.

Get Free Help From a Trusted Counselor

We’ll walk you through your student loan options, answer questions, and help you steer clear of scams at no cost to you.

Jeff Michael
Article written by
Jeff Michael is the author of More Than Money, a debtor education guide for pre-bankruptcy debtor education, and Repair Your Credit and Knock Out Your Debt from McGraw-Hill books. He was a contributor to Tips from The Top: Targeted Advice from America’s Top Money Minds. He lives in Overland Park, Kansas.
an envelope that represents that email that subscribers to nonprofit financial education newsletters.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.