Tackle Student Loan Debt: A Crisis Guide for Borrowers

A post-it note on top of money with student debt and an unhappy smile written on it because of the amount of the student loan debt.

Earning a college degree can expand opportunity and income potential, but for many Americans it also brings a long shadow: student loan debt. About 43 million borrowers in the United States collectively owe more than $1.7 trillion, more than what Americans carry in credit card balances or auto loans. The strain is not limited to recent graduates. Some borrowers are still making payments decades after they first stepped onto a campus.

A college education still matters. It can shape a career and raise lifetime earnings. Yet tuition has climbed faster than most families can comfortably manage, and too many students sign promissory notes without fully understanding what repayment will look like. This guide takes a clear look at how student loans fit into the broader debt picture, what repayment plans are available, and which relief programs may help borrowers steady their finances.

Understanding the Student Loan Debt Crisis

How Much Student Debt Is There?

Total outstanding student loan debt now tops $1.7 trillion. The majority comes from federal student loans, including Direct Loans and Parent PLUS Loans. While millennials and Generation Z hold a large share of the balance, older borrowers are far from immune. Many are still paying for degrees earned years ago, or for loans they took out to help a child attend school.

Part of the pressure comes from today’s labor market. Advanced credentials are often expected, even in fields that do not always guarantee strong starting salaries. Law school, medical school, and many graduate programs require heavy borrowing up front. What is less discussed is how interest accrues, how monthly student loan payments are calculated, and how long the repayment period can stretch if income does not keep pace.

Federal vs. Private Student Loans

There are two primary types of student loans:

  • Federal loans backed by the federal government. These typically include options such as income-driven repayment plans, access to student loan forgiveness programs, and other student aid protections.
  • Private loans issued by banks, credit unions, or other loan servicers. These usually carry fewer safety nets and may have stricter repayment terms.

Understanding which type you have is critical. Federal student aid generally provides more flexibility. Borrowers may qualify for plans like the SAVE Plan, Income-Based Repayment, or Income-Contingent Repayment. These programs tie your monthly payment to your income and family size, which can make payments more manageable during lean years.

Why Student Debt Is a National Issue

Student debt is no longer a niche concern. As higher education costs have risen, so has the average balance per borrower. Policy changes have not always kept up with the realities graduates face once they enter the workforce.

Some borrowers simply do not earn enough to cover their loan payments comfortably. Others experience setbacks such as disability, job loss, or increased living expenses. In certain cases, borrowers report confusion or inadequate assistance from their student loan servicers, leading to complaints filed with the Department of Education or the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

In June 2023, the Supreme Court struck down the Biden administration’s broad student debt relief proposal. Since then, attention has shifted to narrower forms of relief pursued through executive authority and existing programs. Options such as borrower defense to repayment, teacher loan forgiveness, loan rehabilitation, and Public Service Loan Forgiveness still provide structured paths toward debt cancellation for those who meet the eligibility requirements.

Options for Federal Student Loans (Repayment and Forgiveness)

1. Income-Driven Repayment (IDR)/Income Contingent Repayment

Income-driven repayment plans, such as SAVE, ICR, and IBR, are designed to reflect what you actually earn, not just what you owe. Your monthly payment is calculated using your income and family size. For many borrowers, that lowers the required payment and reduces the risk of falling behind. If you remain in the program for the full repayment period, usually 20 to 25 years, any remaining balance may be forgiven under current federal law.

2. Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF Program)

The PSLF program applies to borrowers who work full time for a government agency or qualifying nonprofit organization. After 120 qualifying payments made under an eligible income-driven repayment plan, the remaining balance can be forgiven. Teachers, nurses, firefighters, and other public service employees often pursue this path, though the paperwork and certification requirements must be handled carefully along the way.

3. Loan Rehabilitation and Consolidation Loans

If a loan has gone into default, rehabilitation offers a structured way back. The borrower agrees to make a series of on-time payments, and once completed, the loan can return to good standing. Consolidation loans take a different approach. They combine multiple federal loans into one new loan with a single payment schedule, which can simplify repayment and reduce confusion about due dates.

4. Total and Permanent Disability Discharge

Borrowers who cannot maintain employment because of a qualifying permanent disability may seek a Total and Permanent Disability discharge through the Department of Education. If approved, the remaining loan balance can be canceled.

A woman holding a sign that reads student loan depicting the student loan debt crisis.

What Else Contributes to American Debt?

While student loan payments are a major source of stress, Americans also struggle with other types of debt:

Mortgages

The largest form of household debt in the U.S., mortgages can also become overwhelming. Missed monthly payments may qualify borrowers for deferment, loan modification, or refinancing.

Get help: Foreclosure assistance is available

Auto Loans

These loans can be costly, especially when interest rates are high. Many buyers underestimate the fees and loan terms, which leads to repayment challenges down the line.

More resources: What to do when behind on your car payments.

Credit Card Debt

With high interest and minimal protections, credit card debt is a fast-growing issue. Strategies like the debt snowball (paying off smallest balances first) and debt avalanche (targeting high-interest debts) can help.

Learn more: Debt Repayment: Doing the Math

Tips for Managing Student Debt Effectively

  • Review your credit report on a regular basis. Student loan debt can influence your credit standing, especially if payments are late or accounts fall into default.
  • Stay in contact with your loan servicer. Many struggling borrowers miss out on benefits simply because they are unaware of changes to their IDR plan or updated guidance from the Department of Education.
  • Consider income driven repayment idr early if your annual income does not comfortably support your required payment. Enrolling in an idr plan can reduce monthly pressure and keep federal student loans in good standing.
  • Submit complaints to the Department of Education if you receive inaccurate or misleading information from a loan servicer. Document conversations and keep copies of all correspondence.
  • Monitor developments in student loan debt relief and student loan debt forgiveness policy. Even after the Supreme Court blocked broad cancellation efforts, targeted forgiveness programs and administrative adjustments have continued.

Final Thoughts on Student Loan Debt Relief and Forgiveness Programs

Repaying federal student loans is rarely simple, especially when balances feel far removed from what was borrowed for a valuable education. Some borrowers will fully repaid their loans through steady payments. Others may qualify to receive forgiveness through income based repayment, income contingent repayment, or other income driven repayment idr options.

If your balance feels immovable, do not assume debt relief is out of reach. Student loan debt relief strategies often require paperwork, patience, and careful follow-through, but they can provide meaningful benefits over time. For student loan borrowers with modest annual income relative to what they owe, an IDR plan can create a path toward long-term student loan debt forgiveness while keeping payments manageable along the way.

Need Help with Your Student Loan Debt or Other Debt?

Still not sure where to go from here? No matter what type of debt you are in, our expert coaches are ready to help you find the debt solution that works for you. Contact us today to learn how you can achieve financial freedom.

Sources:

Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System

Article written by
Jeff Michael
Jeff Michael is the author of More Than Money, a debtor education guide for pre-bankruptcy debtor education, and Repair Your Credit and Knock Out Your Debt from McGraw-Hill books. He was a contributor to Tips from The Top: Targeted Advice from America’s Top Money Minds. He lives in Overland Park, Kansas.